Fitness: When Crossfit goes horribly wrong

The one thing that I love about the world of fitness is that people are always innovating, trying new things to help people become more fit and active. We need that sort of innovation so badly.

What I also like is that these types of innovations draw new people into active lifestyles. We need more of that!

But there are times when half-cocked instruction meets amateur exercisers, and this is where things can go terribly wrong. Fitness “students” trust their instructors to show them how to properly perform an exercise, and when that doesn’t happen, people overestimate their abilities, build bad habits and rarely achieve the results their looking for.

Worse yet, people get injured.

Crossfit is a fast-growing and effective exercise phenomenon that has become very popular. It combines high-intensity cardio work, weightlifting (sometimes Olympic-style) body-weight work and other exercises all done in a way that taxes the muscles and cardiovascular system of the person who is doing it. It’s become so big that there are actually televised Crossfit competitions on ESPN.

But I have a serious problem with people who are being incorrectly coached on exercise technique, particularly when it comes to Olympic-style lifts such as cleans, snatches, clean-and-jerks and deadlifts. These are great lifts, but they aren’t as simple as a bench press or weightlifting machines. They are very technique-driven, and breaking form can be injurious.

When I saw the video below, I thought it had to be a joke. But it’s not. These people were serious. And the form exhibited — and encouraged by trainers — was seriously bad.

This is the text accompanying the video, which describes is thusly:

Taken from an event with veteran CrossFit athletes. Hitting axle clean and jerks. Supervised by Strongman Certified Coaches. Axle weight is about 10-15lbs. This lift is not a standard Clean and Jerk.

“Veteran” atheltes? “Certified” coaches? All this experience and training led to this?

Notice the incorrect initial grip. It’s fine for a standard deadlift, but not a clean. And then there’s the fumbling around with the weight on the hip, back twisted back awkwardly as the lifter readjusts to a proper grip (it looks like they’re playing bass guitar in a rock band!). And the overall bad form that barely uses the true driver of power on the lift — the legs.

How in the world did these people not seriously tear up their backs?

Here is a video of a properly executed “axle clean and jerk.”

Proper grip, proper form, good use of the legs. Yep, that’s how it’s done.

My hope is that somewhere along the way, the exercisers in the first video can achieve their fitness goals and gain self-confidence while also learning good form. Here’s also hoping that this is not the direction Crossfit is going. Encouraging poor form and performance will only lead to injury and disappointment, and that is a failure on the part of the coaches and a disservice to the trainees.

Bob Doucette

On Twitter @RMHigh7088

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Fitness: When Crossfit goes horribly wrong

  1. Yo thats a true form for axle clean (usually and jerk). Its called a continental clean not saying it is executed exactly here but opposite grip to transition is a style. If you want your mind blown look at opposite hand grip to zercher squat position to akward hand transfer I think it is called a Kershishan clean. If you can press an axle then sometimes you just got to figure out how to clean it.

    • I think I’m going to go with bad form on this, but if it is indeed a real form of the lift, it’s obviously poorly executed and poorly coached in that video. Which goes back to the original point: learning and mastering Olympic lifts takes time. You can’t just take people off the streets and then have folks do it without knowing how to do it right.

    • This is exactly the direction that CrossFit is going in. From ridiculously poor form, and dangerous, techniques like what’s shown here to the equally-poor form with kettlebells, it’s a recipe for injury.

      • That’s one of my problems with it. More quality control and a tweak of the workouts would make is sustainable, but it’s going to take a serious overhaul of the whole system. Conceptually, Crossfit wants to take ‘real world’ actions and turn that into a fast-paced, competitive and vigorous workout. But the instance you’re talking about, plus the bad Olympic lifts and kip stuff? Not a fan, at least not like that.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s